Definitional issues[ edit ] Rights are widely regarded as the basis of law, but what if laws are bad? Some theorists suggest civil disobedience is, itself, a right, and it was advocated by thinkers such as Henry David ThoreauMartin Luther King Jr.
Is Health Care an Inalienable Right? Essay What is an inalienable right?
As documented in The Declaration of Independence, these rights include: In addition to these rights there are those in the Bill of Rights, which we are familiar with. So, knowing these rights and knowing that they operate on the same general principle of being given at the point of birth, does health care have a place among them?
It could be said that health care is not an inalienable right because it is not mentioned in the Constitution. It does not say to provide it.
The legal section of The Free Dictionary states that the General Welfare Clause allows Congress to spend money for the general welfare but not the power to pass laws for the general welfare.
Health care is not a right because it is a service. It is a material good that must be paid for. Material goods include medical equipment and doctors and nurses. Emergency services and routine check-ups are not free. Someone had to buy those hospital beds, antibiotics, wheelchairs, etc.
If health care was a right, and not a service, there would not be as many doctors and nurses because there is no trade off with medical school and the profession. Guaranteeing health care as a right will lead to an increase in demand and a decrease in the quality of care. A person cannot go to the grocery store and demand food simply because of their right to life.
They must pay for it because the supplier is providing food at a convenience. The store purchased groceries from a wholesaler so that they could provide it without the general public needing to cultivate their own. The same goes for health care.
If someone is injured and seeks medical attention, in most cases it will not be free. As a doctor who had to pay their way through medical school, there must be an exchange of something with ample value to receive their labor.
Hence, health care is a service. If we were able to shop around for medical services based on doctor and skills, there would be competitive pricing and incentive for doctors and nurses to achieve the highest adeptness in their field.
Rosenberger suggests as an alternative, tax incentives to the general public for charitable support to hospitals. Allowing health care to be driven by the free market without government intervention would increase competition and the motivation for providing high quality medical technology and services.
Undoubtedly, by accepting health care as an entitlement, an inalienable right is being created. And the creator is Congress.
Beck goes on to say that if rights can be created they can very well be taken away, such as our freedom of speech and the ability to bear arms and certainly health care if it becomes an object of entitlement.From Disgust to Humanity: Sexual Orientation and Constitutional Law (Inalienable Rights Series) [Martha C.
Nussbaum] on iridis-photo-restoration.com *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. A distinguished professor of law and philosophy at the University of Chicago, a prolific writer and award-winning thinker. Key facts. The WHO Constitution () envisages “ the highest attainable standard of health as a fundamental right of every human being.” Understanding health as a human right creates a legal obligation on states to ensure access to timely, acceptable, and affordable health care of appropriate quality as well as to providing for the underlying determinants of health.
President Obama believes that health care is a right for every American. This is a perversion of the Founding Fathers’ idea of rights. There is an abundance of problems associated with ObamaCare but not enough attention has been paid to the dangerous philosophy behind the law.
Jan 27, · Yahoo Answers Sign in Sign in Mail ⚙ Help Account Info; Help; Suggestions; Send Feedback. On the other hand, health care cannot be considered an inalienable right since it necessarily involves the external assistance of care professionals, administrative policy and infrastructure, financial support, etc., and even doctors sometimes must become patients.
American Patriot Party. Welcome to the American Patriot Party National Headquarters and Oregon Patriot Party State Chapter, The Party that Defends and Secures the True Definition of Inalienable Rights through Education of the Laws of the Declaration of Independence and Bill of Rights, The American Patriots Party.